Skip to main content

CITM

Are Probiotic Drinks Good Evidence Shows

From walking down any grocery aisle, you will see them: kefir, kombucha, drinkable yogurt, probiotic sodas, and gut shots offering improved digestion, stronger immunity and more energy. The probiotic drinks are one of the quickest growing sectors in wellness. But are they really healthy, or is it all marketing?

The straight answer is in the middle. This guide will explain what probiotic drinks are, what they can do, what they can’t, what to look for in a quality option, and why the best approach is to use probiotic drinks in conjunction with a larger health plan for your gut health.

What Is a Probiotic Drink?

If you don’t know what a probiotic drink is, it is one that is loaded with living microorganisms, generally probiotic bacteria (or yeasts) that can help maintain your gut microbiome in a healthy balance. The microbiome is the community of trillions of microbes in your digestive tract that assists you digest, enables your immune system, creates vitamins and helps with chemicals related to mood, such as serotonin.

Most drinks containing probiotics are fermented beverages. Common examples include:

  • Kefir Grasses: fermented milk (or water) beverage using kefir grains
  • Kombucha–a fermented tea
  • Yogurt and probiotic drinks (drinkable)
  • Probiotic sodas and juices (typically these add probiotics after processing)
  • Fermented vegetable brines and other traditional beverages like kvass 
Benefits of Probiotic Drinks Do

What Do Probiotic Drinks Do?

People ask what probiotic drinks do, and typically refer to what they do inside the gut. Probiotics help in the following ways:

  • Inoculating good bacteria with harmful ones
  • Supporting the gut lining and barrier and its function
  • Engaging the immune system, including parts residing in the gut
  • Assisting with digesting lactose in fermented dairy 

That’s the theory. The key point to keep in mind is that effects are strain-specific. Not all drinks cite the precise strains or the number of live organisms in them before consumption, and a benefit that may be displayed in connection with one bacterial strain does not necessarily apply to another.

Are Probiotic Drinks Good for You? What the Evidence Shows

There are real benefits to probiotic drinks, however the benefits are not quite as great as marketed.

  • Kefir has the strongest research behind it. It is rich in various types of bacteria and yeasts, and research has shown it may be associated with increased tolerance for lactose, along with some relief of digestive symptoms.
  • Kombucha has less human evidence. Contains organic acids and some active culture, and compounds from tea; clinical studies proving digestive health benefit to humans are limited.
  • Drinkable yogurts are familiar strains, such as Lactobacillus, and may be inexpensive and convenient, but added sugar levels are definitely not uniform.
  • Labels aren’t tightly regulated. The amount and nature of the bacteria in a bottle are not tested under the same highly stringent standards as those used for medications, and may decrease as the product remains on the shelf.

So, is there any good in probiotic drinks? For the majority of individuals, this is a realistic quantity of a low-sugar fermented beverage to incorporate into a well-balanced eating regimen. They do not cure digestive diseases and they are not a substitute for a high-fiber diet.

Who Should Be Cautious With Probiotic Drinks

While probiotics are safe in most cases, they may not be safe for everyone. Talk with a clinician first if you:

  • Are immunocompromised or immune suppressing treatment
  • Pregnant or Nursing, especially from unpasteurized and homemade food items
  • Central Line or serious underlying illness
  • Have a history of SIBO or large issues with histamine intolerance
  • Dairy Free: Kombucha contains trace alcohol from the fermentation process due to its sensitivity to the same 

Fermented beverages, which are typically homemade, are potentially hazardous due to variations in alcohol content and possible contamination. Others also experience tummy discomfort and flatulence initially, so gradually increase quantities.

How to Choose a Good Probiotic Drink

Not all bottles are equal. If you are looking for a list of probiotic drinks to buy, consider:

  1. Low added sugar. Others contain so much sugar that it doesn’t help. Check the list of ingredients and preferably less than 5 to 8 grams of sugar per serving.
  2. “Live and active cultures.” The phrase or the actual name of a specific specific strain, like Lactobacillus or Bifidobacterium, is better, which is a better indicator than the more generic term contains probiotics.
  3. Refrigeration. The live cultures tend to be better preserved in the products that are stored at cold temperature.
  4. Pasteurization after fermentation. Typically, heat-treated products will not have any living organisms left – always check the label.
  5. A base that suits you. If you are not fond of dairy, use water kefir, or use a plant-based version if you’re not a fan of watered products. If you don’t like watered products, pick a lower-caffeine version of kefir.

Don’t Forget the Prebiotics

Only half the story when it comes to probiotics. Fibre (prebiotics) provides nourishment to the good bacteria and they thrive on it. A diverse diet of vegetables, fruits, legumes, oats and whole grains will provide you with ample amounts of nutrition.

In many instances, the best way to help your microbiome is to adopt a fibre-rich diet, rather than any of the drinks that you can buy in a bottle. They work together: Prebiotic fiber makes it easier for the probiotics to survive and the probiotics give beneficial microbes in the food and water.

When Probiotic Drinks Aren’t Enough

If you have excessive flatulence, bowel irregularities, sensitivities to food, weakness or skin issues, it’s probably a far more serious issue with probiotics. Typical causes are:

  • Gut dysbiosis or SIBO (small intestine bacterial overgrowth)
  • Food sensitivities
  • Persevere stress to digestion
  • Low stomach acid or low enzyme activity
  • Leaky Gut (intestinal permeability)
  • Nutrient deficiencies 

In these instances, a second probiotic beverage may have little effect and may even make things worse for some. A stool test, food sensitivity analysis and a careful eye on your diet and stress can provide clues found out.

The Bottom Line

If fermented foods are an ingredient in your diet, probiotic drinks can be a convenient and tasty way to get them, particularly when it comes to kefir or low sugar varieties. However, the research continues to lag behind marketing and while some strains offer more benefits than others, and some individuals respond to them more favorably than others, none of these drinks can be a substitute for a diet rich in fiber, a strategy for dealing with stress, and an action plan for managing underlying digestive conditions.

At the Center for Integrative & Traditional Medicine in Paramus, NJ, we assist patients in eliminating randomness with gut health. We’re looking at digestive function in our gastroenterology services and for those with bloating or digestive irregularities, our natural remedies for IBS guide is a good start. For those looking to create a healthier drinking plan, we’ve also got some more ideas on functional medicine anti-inflammatory drinks, and a complementary one that we’ve been exploring is acupuncture for digestive health. Our internal medicine staff will also order tests that will be part of a comprehensive digestive program, such as colon hydrotherapy, if you choose to use it.

Call and talk with Dr. Roman Finn about a custom made gut health plan that could be a perfect fit for you.

Frequently Asked Questions: Probiotic Drinks

1. What are probiotic drinks?

Probiotic drinks are liquid drinks containing so-called good bacteria or yeast, usually beneficial bacteria or yeast, that help to keep your digestive system healthy. Most of the time, kefir, kombucha, drinkable yoghurt, or probiotic sodas and juices are used.

Moderate amounts of low-sugar probiotic drinks are a good addition to a healthy diet for most non-diseased individuals. The benefits are actual and small, and different in different people and from one strain to another. They are recommended to be used in conjunction with a high fibre diet rather than alone.

Due to the variety of bacteria and yeasts found in kefir, it has the best research support. Kombucha has fewer calories, is lighter and contains less human evidence of digestive benefits. Select sugar low products and choose to drink products containing live, active cultures.

Most people can enjoy a small serving daily without problems. Start with a small amount, watch how your digestion responds, and consider cutting back if you also take a probiotic supplement or notice bloating or gas.

For some, they will get some gas, bloating, or loose stools when they begin. Although the Kombucha is made in a natural way with an even less amount of alcohol and sometimes with caffeine, for those who have a compromised immune system, some people are at risk of infection through the unpasteurized version.

Neither is clearly better for everyone. Fermented drinks provide a mix of microbes plus nutrients, while supplements offer specific, labeled strains. Which is more suitable depends on your goals and health history, so ask a clinician before choosing a supplement for a specific condition.

A lot of people don’t require one. If these symptoms persist–bloating, irregular bowel movements, or food reactions–then testing and a root cause assessment can determine if there are benefits of taking probiotics, making a dietary adjustment or other support.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *